The archive · Games & Play · Product decision · 2015
Her Story makes searching a police video database the whole game — and revives FMV
Sam Barlow's 2015 Her Story turns keyword search over video clips into the core mechanic — a three-BAFTA landmark of interactive fiction.
Sam Barlow
What it had to solve
Barlow wanted a police procedural, but games rarely tackle dialogue-heavy rooms because listening is passive. He also carried years of frustration from mo-cap shoots whose performances the facial rig could not reproduce.
How it works
Her Story, released in June 2015 by former Silent Hill writer Sam Barlow, gives players a single job: sit at a mid-90s desktop, type search terms into a police database, and watch the short video clips that come back. The footage covers seven 1994 interviews with one woman about her missing husband; the clips are fragments, and the murder story only assembles as players dig out keywords and re-order what they have seen.
The idea grew out of Barlow's frustration with motion capture on Silent Hill and Legacy of Kain: Dead Sun, where subtle performances were lost to rigs and animation. His solution was to shoot actual video with Viva Seifert and make the search itself the game, describing the mechanic to PC Gamer as essentially 'Googling' your way through a mystery, with a five-clip-per-search limit forcing players to search smarter instead of faster.
The gamble was that listening and investigation could be as gripping as combat. Critics agreed: PC Gamer gave it 90 and called it 'the best FMV game ever made,' and it won Best Narrative at The Game Awards 2015 plus three BAFTA Games Awards in 2016 (Debut Game, Game Innovation, Mobile & Handheld). Engadget later credited it with creating a richer non-linear, interactive narrative form than branching choices, one that treats the player as a detective rather than a menu-user.
Why it lands
- Typing keywords into a video database made passive listening feel dynamic — the interface, not action, was the game.
- Real footage beat animated approximation: Barlow noted that L.A. Noire's elaborate mo-cap solution ended in the uncanny valley, while video stayed natural.
- The five-results-per-search limit forced players to think like investigators instead of consuming clips in order.
- One actor, one room, one database made a tiny budget and a huge ambition fit together.
What it did
PC Gamer scored it 90 and called it the best FMV game ever made; it won Best Narrative at The Game Awards 2015 and three BAFTAs in 2016 (Debut Game, Game Innovation, Mobile & Handheld), and opened the door for a wave of FMV and database-driven narrative games.
What you can take
When the hard problem is preserving a human performance, the elegant fix is to reframe the problem: keep the raw video and make the interface itself the interactive layer.
Since then
Her Story became the hinge point for a revived FMV wave and a template for database-driven mysteries. Barlow scaled the mechanic up with Telling Lies in 2019 (full conversations, searchable video) and Immortality in 2022; other studios pushed the same search-and-reassemble format for years after. It also re-framed the debate about whether interactivity has to mean combat, branching menus, or player action at all.
Sources
- The story behind Her Story
- Watching as Detectives: The Truth Behind 'Her Story'
- British Academy Games Awards Winners Announced
spotted an error? The archive wants to know.
Your turn
You just read one. Describe the brief you are staring at, and see who has been given the same problem.
Free account · 3 free questions · no card