The archive · Marketing & Growth · Marketing decision · 2023–2024
Heinz names and shames 'Ketchup Fraud' — 438M impressions, 33 new accounts in a month
Catching restaurants refilling Heinz bottles with generic ketchup, Heinz turned fans into fraud-reporters — and gained 33 accounts in under a month.
Kraft Heinz · Heinz Ketchup · Rethink
What it had to solve
Restaurants quietly refilled Heinz bottles with cheaper generic ketchup to save money, so the 'It Has To Be Heinz' promise was being betrayed at the table — and customers were posting about it.
How it works
A viral Snapchat video showed a restaurant employee refilling an empty Heinz bottle with generic ketchup. Social listening showed the behavior was everywhere: restaurants worldwide were topping up Heinz bottles with cheaper sauces to save money, and customers could taste the difference. Heinz's response was not a legal fight but a campaign: Ketchup Fraud.
Rethink turned the brand's long-standing line 'It Has To Be Heinz' into a twist — 'Even when it isn't Heinz, it has to be Heinz' — and produced caught-in-the-act style print ads, out-of-home in New York and Chicago, TV spots, and a full-page New York Times feature. Then it invited consumers to report restaurants committing the 'crime' on a dedicated website, and even let restaurants submit themselves anonymously.
The brand then reached out to the named restaurants and supplied real Heinz ketchup, converting the fraud into business: 33 new accounts in under a month, including re-signing Boston's Fenway Park, worth more than $250,000 in gross sales volume.
The campaign reached over 438 million impressions with 92% positive sentiment and engagement 128 times the benchmark. Heinz sales rose 8% year over year and market share gained 0.6 points at a time when inflation was pushing consumers and businesses toward cheaper products. It won Gold at Cannes Lions in Outdoor (2023) and PR (2024), and the One Show 2024 Best of Print & Promotional.
Why it lands
- It used a real consumer-observed behavior (refilled bottles) instead of an invented problem.
- Fans became the campaign's enforcement arm, reporting offenders by name.
- The tagline twist — 'Even when it isn't Heinz, it has to be Heinz' — flattered the brand without arguing.
- Every reported restaurant became a sales lead: Heinz closed the loop by supplying the real product.
- The 'crime' framing made a quality-control issue entertaining and shareable.
What it did
438M+ impressions and 92% positive sentiment, engagement 128x above benchmark; 33 new accounts in under a month (including Fenway Park) worth over $250K in sales volume; Heinz sales up 8% and market share up 0.6 points; One Show 2024 Best of Print & Promotional.
What you can take
A brand's biggest threat can be a cheap imitation wearing its own label. Instead of suing, Heinz made fans the enforcement arm — turning a quality threat into shareable participation and new accounts.
Since then
The campaign is credited with reversing Heinz's exposure to ketchup substitution during a cost-of-living squeeze: sales rose 8%, share gained 0.6 points, and Heinz added 33 accounts in its first month, including Fenway Park. It became a reference case for brand-defense creativity, winning Gold Lions at Cannes in Outdoor (2023) and PR (2024), One Show 2024 Best of Print & Promotional, and an Effie entry. The reporting site stayed live as a standing channel for consumers to flag restaurants, turning a service-quality threat into an owned-media participation loop.
Sources
- Heinz rejects imposters for 'Ketchup Fraud' campaign
- Kraft Heinz — 'Ketchup Fraud' (2023 Agency of the Year case)
- One Show 2024 — Heinz Ketchup Fraud (winners archive)
- Put an end to Ketchup Fraud (campaign site)
- 亨氏：番茄酱诈骗 (Heinz: Ketchup Fraud)
spotted an error? The archive wants to know.
Your turn
You just read one. Describe the brief you are staring at, and see who has been given the same problem.
Free account · 3 free questions · no card