The archive · Public & Social · Strategic decision · 2014–2015
Grenoble frees its streets of 326 billboards, planting trees and notice boards (2015)
Grenoble let its JCDecaux ad contract lapse, removed 326 street billboards and put trees and free citizen notice boards in their place — a European first.
Ville de Grenoble (City of Grenoble)
What it had to solve
Green mayor Éric Piolle won the 2014 municipal election partly on a promise to free Grenoble's streets of advertising, after a 2013 poll found three-quarters of residents felt the ads were invasive.
How it works
Grenoble, a city of about 160,000 in the French Alps, had signed a ten-year street-furniture contract with JCDecaux that let the advertising group install billboards, advertising columns and bus-shelter panels in public space. When the contract ran out at the end of 2014, the newly elected Green mayor Éric Piolle made good on a campaign promise: he did not renew it, and announced that advertising would be dismantled and replaced with greenery.
The numbers made the decision concrete. From January to April 2015 JCDecaux removed 326 panels — 227 street-level 'sucettes', 20 advertising columns and 64 large billboards — freeing more than 2,000 square metres of public space. In their place the city planted about 50 young trees and made room for free notice boards where residents, associations and cultural organisations could post without paying.
The city argued that the sacrifice was small: the old contract had paid about €600,000 a year, and a renewed deal was expected to be worth only about €150,000 as the industry moved to digital screens, which the mayor did not want in an 'apaisée' (calmer) city. A 2013 survey had found three-quarters of residents felt advertising was becoming invasive, and opponents of the move still criticised the lost revenue — roughly 1% of the city's €370 million budget — and the removal of the familiar advertising columns.
Six months later, before-and-after photos by franceinfo showed the change was real: most of the 326 panels were gone, a row of five trees stood where a billboard had faced a square, and the city said it had planted more trees than promised. Not everything disappeared — bus-shelter ads remained under a separate transport-authority contract — and Grenoble began a longer revision of rules on private signs, which it pursued over the following years.
Why it lands
- The city used a natural deadline — the expiring ten-year contract — instead of fighting a legal battle, so the change cost little and faced no compensation claims.
- Replacing ads with trees and free citizen notice boards made an abstract policy (less advertising) into visible, positive public goods that residents could touch.
- The revenue sacrifice was honest and small: €600,000 a year was under 1% of the budget, and renewal would have paid only a quarter of that, weakening the commercial case for keeping ads.
- A mayor who campaigned on the promise turned the removal into proof of follow-through, which made the decision newsworthy and gave other French cities a repeatable template.
What it did
By July 2015 almost all 326 panels were gone, with more trees planted than originally announced, and Grenoble was being called the first European city to renounce billboard revenue. The move became a reference point: France's anti-advertising groups grew from five in 2016 to 29 by 2020, Paris paused plans for new digital boards after 95% of more than 2,000 consultation participants opposed them, and Grenoble itself began revising rules on private and illuminated signs.
What you can take
An expiring contract is a chance to redefine what public space is for: Grenoble traded shrinking ad rent for trees and citizen notice boards, making the choice visible enough for other cities to copy.
Since then
Bus and tram-shelter advertising survived because that contract belonged to the regional transport authority, and it was later renewed, so Grenoble never became fully ad-free. The city still pursued private advertising, launching a local-rule revision to end large 8 m² and illuminated signs. The 2015 removal became a reference point for France's anti-advertising movement — activist groups grew from five in 2016 to 29 by 2020 — and Paris paused new digital boards after most consultation participants opposed them.
Sources
- French city Grenoble bans advertising in favour of trees
- Grenoble se détourne de la publicité au profit de "sa vie de quartier" (maire)
- Avant/Après: la pub a déserté les rues de Grenoble
- The growing global movement to end outdoor advertising
spotted an error? The archive wants to know.
Your turn
You just read one. Describe the brief you are staring at, and see who has been given the same problem.
Free account · 3 free questions · no card