What it had to solve
Amazon's app icon had shown a shopping trolley for years; the January 2021 redesign put a parcel, smile and tape on phones worldwide, meant to 'spark anticipation, excitement, and joy when customers start their shopping journey'.
The idea
Redesign based on a brown parcel with the signature smile and a folded strip of blue tape — swapping the flat tape that read as a moustache.
How it works
The icon had been trialled in a few countries before launch; after the resemblance feedback spread, Amazon quickly changed the design to a folded, angled strip of tape and rolled out the revision.
What it did
The rollback drew both mockery ('look for the cardboard Hitler', one customer tweeted) and designer praise — Studio LWD's Laura Weldon said it 'reflects well on Amazon that they listened to their customers'.
Background
In January 2021 Amazon launched a redesign of its main shopping-app icon: the familiar smile set on a brown parcel, crossed by a strip of blue shipping tape. Within weeks, observers noted the angled tape sat over the smile in a way that resembled Adolf Hitler's toothbrush moustache, and the story made mainstream news. The previous icon had simply shown a shopping trolley.
Amazon moved quickly, changing the design so the tape appears folded at an angle rather than lying flat across the smile, and told BBC News the first icon had been trialled in only a few countries before the change. The company's stated intent for the icon — 'to spark anticipation, excitement, and joy when customers start their shopping journey on their phone, just as they do when they see our boxes on their doorstep' — survived the redesign; the flat tape did not.
The episode played out as design commentary and customer comedy in equal measure. Brand agency Coley Porter Bell's chief executive Vicky Bullen said the parcel tape 'will immediately be associated as a Hitleresque moustache... not the best association for a brand that wants to create delight on the doorstep', while customers joked their parents would be lost — 'I'll tell them to look for the cardboard Hitler'. Brand designer Laura Weldon took the longer view: 'It reflects well on Amazon that they listened to their customers.'
Why it lands
The toothbrush moustache is among the most instantly recognised shapes in the world, so any diagonal strip over a smile invites the comparison.
Context did the damage: the tape sat directly above the curved smile, completing the face the logo already drew.
Amazon's fast revision limited the damage and turned a blunder into a customer-listening story.
A small in-country trial missed what a global rollout multiplied — icon meanings are tested by scale, not focus groups.
What you can take
Test icons in the wild before global rollout: on a phone screen, every shape inherits every association the internet has ever made.
Since then
The folded-tape icon replaced the original across platforms by March 2021; BBC News covered the change on 3 March 2021, with no further changes to the parcel-and-smile concept reported.
FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE