The archive · Marketing & Growth · Marketing decision · 2014–2016
Allstate's Mayhem robs a couple's replica home live at the Sugar Bowl — two Silver Effies
At the 2015 Sugar Bowl, Allstate's Mayhem sold a real couple's 'belongings' live online — 18M hits, 18% sales lift, two Silver Effies.
Allstate Insurance Company · Leo Burnett/Arc Worldwide
What it had to solve
Allstate's Mayhem character personified everyday dangers, but young homeowners don't fear burglary, so the brand needed to dramatize a threat people couldn't see. Research found a large share of burglars now scout targets on social media, making oversharing the perfect modern vulnerability.
How it works
By 2014 Allstate's Mayhem — the human personification of everyday hazards, played by Dean Winters — had been warning viewers about accidents for years. But burglary felt distant to young homeowners, so the brand set out to dramatize a specific modern vulnerability: telling social media when you are away. Research cited by the team put the share of burglars using social media to find targets at roughly seven in ten.
On New Year's Day 2015, during the Allstate Sugar Bowl, a real couple, Matt and Shannon, posted about attending the game. While they watched from the stadium, Mayhem appeared on TV inside a replica of their home and started selling their 'possessions' in real time: eight sequential TV spots and eighteen online videos built the story, while the @Mayhem Twitter account and #MayhemSale hashtag pushed items onto MayhemSale.com.
The stunt was real enough that shoppers bought nearly 300 replica items — a car listed at $34,170 went for $200. MayhemSale.com drew 18 million hits during the game and crashed more than once, #MayhemSale became the top-trending topic on Twitter worldwide, and Allstate reported an 18% lift in home-insurance sales for the month. The 2016 North American Effies gave the work two Silvers, plus a Bronze for the wider 'Mayhem is Everywhere' sustained campaign.
Why it lands
- The campaign made an abstract statistic feel personal: the victims were a real couple whose actual posts and possessions were part of the story.
- Live TV, social and e-commerce ran on one clock, so following the 'crime' in real time was itself the entertainment.
- Selling real goods for real money made the metaphor undeniable — people could watch the sale happen, not just hear a warning.
- The 18 million visits came with almost no paid amplification: the event's own drama generated the coverage.
What it did
MayhemSale.com drew 18 million hits during the game and #MayhemSale was the top-trending Twitter topic worldwide; home-insurance sales lifted 18% that month, and the work won two Silver Effies at the 2016 North American Effie Awards.
What you can take
An invisible risk becomes memorable when dramatized in audience behavior: instead of lecturing, Allstate let millions watch Mayhem exploit oversharing live — participation replaced persuasion.
Since then
The Sugar Bowl stunt became the biggest set piece in the long-running Mayhem campaign, which had already won a Gold Effie in 2012 and grew into one of Allstate's most durable assets; under the marketing leadership of the era, Allstate's campaigns collected 17 Effies in total. The 'AwareShare' lesson site built for the campaign lived on at Allstate.com, and the execution became a reference point for integrating live events with e-commerce and social media.
Sources
- Winner Spotlight: Allstate Insurance Company & Leo Burnett/Arc Worldwide, 'Social Savvy Burglar'
- Allstate's 'Mayhem' Is Biggest Winner of College Bowl
- Social Savvy Burglar
- Lisa Cochrane — Advertising Week New York 2014 speaker page
spotted an error? The archive wants to know.
Your turn
You just read one. Describe the brief you are staring at, and see who has been given the same problem.
Free account · 3 free questions · no card