D&AD’s 2025 Helan entry credits Blackbow with the identity. Its description connects mountain ridgelines with the letters of HeLAN and interprets the lowercase e as a reference to the Yellow River. These are the entry’s stated design intentions, not measured consumer responses. [1]
Analysis & application
Our interpretation: placing a landscape inside the name can combine an origin cue and a brand identifier in one element. The trade-off is that a more expressive silhouette may make the letters harder to recognize. A compelling explanation does not establish that an unfamiliar reader will see the same meaning without help.
The earlier case repeated the design description and treated immediate recognition and use on every bottle as established outcomes. The reviewed entry supplies neither recognition tests nor a complete rollout inventory. We remove those assertions. Its claim about phonetic clarity remains attributed to the entry rather than presented as a verified result. [1]
Analysis & application
- Specify the audience and the real viewing conditions: shelf, mobile thumbnail or small printed label.
- Compare the expressive wordmark with a plain rendering of the same name, using comparable size and contrast.
- Ask unfamiliar readers to identify the letters before explaining the landscape.
- Record reading errors and origin associations separately; an attractive image may still be misread.
- Revise the hardest-to-read forms, then retest. Preserve the story only where it survives the intended use.
Analysis & application
This test is our proposed method, not a study conducted for Helan. A useful follow-up would report the sample, language familiarity, display conditions and results, alongside actual examples of use. Award-entry descriptions alone do not demonstrate higher sales, stronger recognition or a fully deployed identity.
FOLLOW THE EVIDENCE
The sources
- Helan — D&AD Awards Archive D&AD · dandad.org