The archive · Advertising · Marketing decision · 2009–2010
Domino's 'Pizza Turnaround' admits the old pie was bad — new recipe doubles Q4 results
Domino's stops defending a failing recipe: real employees confront customers calling the crust 'cardboard' and the sauce 'ketchup', then unveil a rebuilt pie.
Domino's Pizza · Crispin Porter + Bogusky
What it had to solve
Years of focus groups and social media had reduced Domino's reputation to 'cardboard crust' and 'ketchup sauce'. Rather than claim the pizza was new and improved, CEO Patrick Doyle and agency Crispin Porter + Bogusky decided the only credible move was to agree with the critics.
How it works
By 2009 Domino's knew exactly what America thought of its pizza: when the company solicited honest feedback, customers called the crust 'cardboard' and the sauce 'ketchup'. The insult had become the brand's reputation, repeated on social media faster than any ad could answer it.
Instead of spinning, Crispin Porter + Bogusky built the campaign around the complaint. Domino's aired commercials and a YouTube documentary where real employees — including CEO Patrick Doyle — faced the critics and explained how the recipe was being reinvented from the crust up, under the banner 'Oh Yes We Did'.
The honesty was backed by action: customer quotes were printed on pizza boxes, reviews ran on Times Square screens, kitchens were live-streamed, and a dedicated website fed in live Twitter and Facebook reactions. When the new pizza launched in all US stores in late December 2009, the proof was public.
Domino's credited the campaign with more than doubling its fourth-quarter results, and QSRweb called the year one of the company's strongest in its history. The stock went from $2.61 in 2008 to $140 by April 2016 as transparency became the brand's platform.
Why it lands
- Agreeing with the critics made the complaint itself the message, so nothing the brand said could be called spin.
- The recipe was genuinely rebuilt, making the admission verifiable rather than cosmetic.
- Using real employees and real quotes instead of actors gave the film documentary credibility.
- Meeting the criticism on YouTube and social media put the answer exactly where the complaint lived.
- Admitting fault rebuilt trust, which later let Domino's take bolder risks with the same agency.
What it did
Domino's credited the new recipe and the ads with more than doubling its fourth-quarter results that year; the campaign became one of the strongest years in its history and its stock rose from $2.61 in 2008 to $140 by April 2016.
What you can take
When the public already believes your product is bad, 'new and improved' is worthless; publicly agreeing with the critics and showing the fix turns your biggest weakness into proof of change.
Since then
The Pizza Turnaround became the reference point for candor-based brand turnarounds and anchored Domino's transformation into a digital-first company; later work built on the same transparency platform, from kitchen live-streams to Emoji Ordering, which won a Cannes Titanium Grand Prix in 2015. QSRweb reported Domino's framing the campaign as 'honesty over risk', and the stock's long climb from $2.61 (2008) to $140 (April 2016) showed the market believed the change.
Sources
- Domino's to Deliver More Than 19.1 Million Slices of Pizza Nationwide on New Year's Holidays
- US' most creative partnerships: Domino's & Crispin Porter & Bogusky
- The Dominos Effect: Honest feedback yielding honest advertising
spotted an error? The archive wants to know.
Your turn
You just read one. Describe the brief you are staring at, and see who has been given the same problem.
Free account · 3 free questions · no card