The archive · Advertising · Marketing decision · 2014
Newcastle fakes the Super Bowl ad it couldn't afford — 1B+ impressions, never aired
Too small for a Super Bowl buy, Newcastle hyped the overblown ad it almost made — teasers, fake stars and focus groups for a spot that never aired.
Newcastle Brown Ale (Heineken USA) · Droga5 New York
What it had to solve
In 2014 Newcastle Brown Ale did not have the roughly $4.5 million a Super Bowl spot cost, so it could not buy airtime — and it could not resist mocking the overhyped ads that would fill the game.
How it works
In January 2014, Newcastle Brown Ale and its agency Droga5 announced they would not buy airtime in that year's Super Bowl — a spot cost about $4.5 million. Instead of sitting out, they called bollocks on the whole big-game advertising machine and built a fully integrated campaign around the epic Super Bowl ad they could have made if they had the money.
Droga5 treated the fake ad like a real blockbuster release: a teaser for the trailer, behind-the-scenes documentaries with the 'stars' who would have appeared — Anna Kendrick and Keyshawn Johnson — and genuine focus groups whose bemused reactions to the fake trailer were themselves released as content. The whole rollout lived on the IfWeMadeIt.com microsite, YouTube and Facebook in the weeks before the game.
When the real Super Bowl ads finally aired, Newcastle released its cheap storyboard version of the would-be spot, complete with party sharks, battle apes and cats on skateboards. The campaign generated over a billion impressions and appeared on nearly every Top Ten Super Bowl list despite never actually airing an ad, and it won the top Blue award in Facebook's 2014 Studio Awards.
Why it lands
- It inverted the big-game logic: the 'making of' became the campaign, so Newcastle competed with Super Bowl ads without paying Super Bowl prices.
- Each teaser was its own piece of content — atomized storytelling that let people enter anywhere and kept the joke running for weeks.
- The fake focus groups added proof to the parody: real consumers reacting to the ridiculous trailer made the satire feel documented, not claimed.
- It stayed on message about the brand's 'No Bollocks' identity — self-mocking, underdog honesty that beer drinkers could laugh along with.
What it did
The campaign racked up over a billion impressions and made nearly every Top Ten Super Bowl list despite never airing, per D&AD's archive entry; it won the top Blue award at the 2014 Facebook Studio Awards, where Facebook's chief creative officer called it a 'big audacious idea' built as a franchise. Newcastle then repeated the trick with 'If We Won' around July 4, 2014.
What you can take
A budget constraint can become the story, not the excuse: advertising the ad you cannot make turns weakness into content — and can outshine brands that bought the slot.
Since then
The stunt became a franchise: Newcastle repeated the ambush with 'If We Won' around July 4, 2014, and returned to the idea in later Super Bowl seasons, while Adweek's Ads of the Year coverage and a string of awards kept 'If We Made It' in agency case-study collections. It remains one of the most-cited examples of making an event you cannot afford to enter.
Sources
- If We Made It — D&AD archive entry
- UK shops fail to win any Facebook Studio Awards
- Newcastle, Droga5 Parody Big Game Ads with 'If We Made It'
- Newcastle Imagines How Great It Would Be If Britain Had Won the Revolutionary War
spotted an error? The archive wants to know.
Your turn
You just read one. Describe the brief you are staring at, and see who has been given the same problem.
Free account · 3 free questions · no card